Failed payment recovery
that wins back the renewal.
Failed payment recovery decides how many subscribers you keep when a card fails. About 1 renewal in 7 fails the first time. The typical store wins back 42%, and top stores 55% to 73%. We set recovery up by the reason each payment failed and by how people pay, then measure it on the money that comes back.
Where failed payments are lost.
Before you change your failed payment recovery, see where the money goes. Our involuntary churn research followed every failed renewal in the stores we run and audit. At the typical store:
renewal charges fails on the first try. Top stores get 89% to 93% through first time.
of failed payments come back. Top stores win back 55% to 73%.
failed payments ends in a pause or a cancellation. It happens before the money comes back.
of failed Shop Pay payments come back, against 62% of failed cards.
Retry an empty account quietly.
A third of failed payments are an empty account. About two in three of those come back, nearly all on a plain retry, with no help from the subscriber. An early email there can give them a reason to leave instead.
Silent retries first
The first retries go out with no message at all. How many depends on how much of your recovery comes from retries alone, read from your own store.
Ask them to top up, not to change cards
When a message does go out, it says the money will be taken again on a set date. Their card is fine; their balance is not.
A small step down in price
A small discount on the later retries, so a balance a few dollars short can clear.
Keep going
Most of the money comes back by the third retry. The retries after the eighth still win back 4% of failed payments at the typical store, so a short schedule leaves money behind.
Ask for a new card when the card is dead.
About a quarter of failed payments are a card that can never be charged again. It was revoked, or the bank said stop. About 1 in 10 of those comes back, and almost only once the subscriber puts in a new card.
Ask on day one
The first message asks for a new card. Waiting through retries on a dead card only uses up the days they would have acted.
One tap to update
The button opens the page where they change the card, already signed in, on a phone.
Fewer retries
Retrying a card the bank has closed changes nothing. So the schedule is short, and the messages do the work.
A new card before a save
If they reach the cancel page while their payment is failing, the offer they see needs a working card first. An offer on a dead card saves nothing.
Route by how each reason really pays.
Banks pass vague reasons. “Do not honor” sounds final, but 46% come back at the typical store, mostly on a plain retry. So each reason goes where it really recovers at your store, not where its name suggests.
Read a year of your own failures
Every reason, how many failed, how many came back, and how: on a retry or with a new card.
Retries where retries work
Reasons that mostly pay on a retry share the quiet schedule.
Messages where only a new card works
Reasons that barely come back without one get the ask on day one.
One home for every reason
Each wording the banks use is grouped under one reason, so none falls through to a default.
Give wallet payers a way back.
When a card payment fails, 62% come back at the typical store. For Shop Pay it is 37% and for Apple Pay 31%. A wallet that fails usually needs the subscriber to come back and pay.
A pay-again link
Wallet payers get a link that lets them pay again in one tap, not a request to update a card they never typed in.
A card as backup
Once the payment clears, ask them to add a card, so the next failure has somewhere to go.
Check PayPal after a move
When a store moves to a new subscription app, PayPal’s permission to charge can be lost. Test a PayPal renewal before the first big billing day.
Every message is a chance to cancel.
At the typical store 14% of failed payments end with the subscriber pausing or cancelling before the money comes back. Where the app shows the timing, about half of those come at the very first notice.
Say what to do, not what went wrong
The subject names the action. The body is three lines and one button, in the first screen on a phone.
The right ask for the reason
Top up for an empty account, a new card for a dead one, pay again for a wallet. The wrong ask reads as a mistake.
Change the message three times, not every retry
The ask, then the ask with a better offer, then what they lose: their price, their points, their next gift.
No cancel button in the email
The way out stays in the portal. The email is there to fix the payment.
How the cancel page holds up is on our cancellation flow benchmarks.
Measure failed payment recovery on finished payments.
A recovery rate read too early counts payments still being retried as lost. Read it on a month whose retries have all run, and split it the way the money really moves.
Finished payments only
Payments still being retried come out of both sides of the sum.
By reason and by how people pay
Recovery for an empty account, a dead card, a card and a wallet, each on its own line.
Cancellations during recovery
How many subscribers paused or cancelled while you were still collecting. It is the number your messages move.
Money, not only payments
What came back in dollars, beside what was lost for good. The typical store loses 8% of its renewal money.
Failed payment recovery we build.
Recovery read
A year of your failed payments by reason and by how people pay, against our benchmarks, with the order to fix things in.
Strategies by reason
Every decline reason routed to where it really recovers at your store, in Loop, Recharge or Skio.
The retry schedule
Quiet retries where retries work, a longer run where late retries still pay, and a small step down in price.
Messages that fix the payment
The right ask for each reason, in your brand’s voice, changed at three points, never retry by retry.
Wallet and PayPal paths
A pay-again link for wallet payers, a backup card, and a PayPal check after any move between apps.
Measurement
Recovery on finished payments, by reason and payment method, with cancellations during recovery beside it.
Proof on named accounts.
subscription churn, Frøya Organics. Read the case study
quarterly growth from the subscription engine, Zapply UK. Read the case study
Repeat customer revenue is up like 50%. So that’s really good. There’s lots of positive things from last month.
Our email and campaign conversion is up 4× since we started. Your team just gets the women’s-health customer.
We really saw a huge impact, especially in the beginning - a huge boost, both in revenue and revenue share. You guys are true professionals, you have a very creative team.
Super happy. Best retention agency in the business.
Find the renewals you could win back.
We read your failed payments by reason and by how people pay, and show what a retry wins back and what needs a new card. Free, run by the founder, no contract.
Questions founders ask.
How do you recover failed subscription payments?
Read why each payment failed. Retry an empty account quietly, and ask for a new card at once when the card is dead. Give wallet payers a link to pay again. Keep retrying past the first few tries, and measure on payments whose retries have finished.
Should recovery change with the reason the payment failed?
Yes. An empty account comes back about two times in three, nearly always on a plain retry. A revoked card comes back about 1 time in 10, and only with a new card. One schedule for both wastes the first and gives up on the second.
What is dunning management?
Dunning management is how a business collects a payment that failed: the retries, the messages and what happens at the end. For subscription brands it decides how much involuntary churn you keep.
How many times should you retry a failed subscription payment?
More than most stores think. Most of the money comes back by the third retry. Yet the retries after the eighth still win back 4% of failed payments at the typical store.
Why do subscribers cancel after a failed payment?
The message about the failed payment is often the first reminder that they are subscribed. At the typical store 14% of failed payments end in a pause or a cancellation before the money comes back.
Does this work on Loop, Recharge and Skio?
Yes. Each app has its own retry schedule, messages and reports. We set the same plan up in whichever one you run, alongside Klaviyo.
Keep reading.
Involuntary churn benchmarks
Which failed payments come back, by decline reason, retry and payment method.
Cancellation flow benchmarks
How many saved subscribers stay, and which saves last.
Subscription churn strategy
How to keep subscribers past the third order, moment by moment.
Subscription marketing agency
We run this as a service, from the offer to the renewal.
YOCTO is the Klaviyo marketing agency for DTC and subscription brands. We run customer retention, subscription marketing, email marketing, deliverability and SMS, and we start with a free Klaviyo audit.
Your failed payments,
won back.
We read your failed payments against these benchmarks and give you the list of what to change, in the order it pays.
